The Ballad of James and Madeleine

SPECTRE promotional art

SPECTRE promotional art

By Nicolás Suszczyk, Guest Writer

“As the daughter of an assassin, she can understand Bond in a way others cannot.”

This is how the official SPECTRE synopsis describes Madeleine Swann, the female lead character of the 24th James Bond adventure, about to hit the stores in DVD and Blu Ray home video formats.

Played by French actress Léa Seydoux, known for movies like Woody Allen’s Midnight in Paris, Mission Impossible: Ghost Protocol and the acclaimed Blue is the Warmest Color, her character was built by scribes Jez Butterworth, Neal Purvis, Robert Wade and John Logan to –- apparently –- give Daniel Craig’s James Bond the first and only happy ending he’s ever had in the series.

The first encounter 007 has with Madeleine Swann is at the Hoffler Klinik in Austria. Posing as a patient, Bond visits her and suspects that Swann, a doctor in psychiatry graduated in the Sorbonne who worked with Medicine Sans Frontiers, is hiding from someone in the clinic. Of course, the secret agent was led there by her disgraced father, none other than his previous Quantum nemesis Mr. White, who took his life right after Bond promised to protect her of the tentacles of SPECTRE.

She first resists to Bond, but ultimately she sees he’s the only one who can keep her alive after her hideout clinic is discovered by SPECTRE agent Mr. Hinx.

Much in the way of previous Bond girls Natalya Simonova (from GoldenEye) and Octopussy, she dislikes 007’s violent life, seeing him as a man who is the same kind as her father: determined to leave him right after he returns for a final assignment to stop Denbigh, the mole placed at the British Intelligence by the organization leader Franz Oberhauser, aka Ernst Stavro Blofeld.

There is, in contrast to the previous affairs of Craig’s Bond, a happy ending this time as 007 opts to leave the wounded Blofeld alive instead of shooting him. As the Special Forces arrest the SPECTRE leader, the happy couple walk together -– holding hands — across the Westminster Bridge.

Madeleine Swann is no match for Vesper Lynd, Tracy Di Vicenzo or even Paris Carver when it comes to exploring Bond’s human side. Yet, the idea of Madeleine’s persona was originally very good and sadly more of her connection with 007 would have been explored a lot better.

“Is this really what you want? Living in the shadows, hunting, being hunted, always looking behind you? Always alone?” the doctor asks a white tuxedo-clad Bond as they have a soft-light dinner travelling in the Oriental Desert Express trough Morocco.

In one of the first drafts of the (leaked) script, the couple had a conversation that included Vesper, Eva Green’s ill-fated character from Casino Royale, the film that opened the arc that SPECTRE has apparently closed.

“You’re not like my father at all. He was cold, but you’re wounded,” the doctor said. As she asks him if he has ever been in love, he replies “Once. She died.” Quickly, he tells her he “dealt with it.”

The Bond-Swann relationship would have had a bigger emotional impact if more deep dialogue was added as the first draft shows. If Vesper Lynd and her death were the main subjects of the first two films of Craig era, the girl who makes him move on should have deep-delved into his emotions.

Show the audiences how Vesper was important then and why Madeleine is important now. A contrast between the two characters and how Bond slowly recovers what he lost during that black day in Venice nine years before. In the same way the connection between SPECTRE and the previous villains isn’t fully explained, the importance of Madeleine can’t overshadow the image of Vesper in an emotional context.

The barn scene between Bond and Tracy in On Her Majesty’s Secret Service, or the Pierce Brosnan-Izabella Scorupco scene at the Cuban beach in GoldenEye, or Bond’s love declaration to Vesper at the Lake DiGarda in Casino Royale, just to name a few scenes. These are wonderful examples on how to explore Bond’s feelings.

SPECTRE is a celebration of all things Bond in terms of excitement, perhaps the closest one to “a classic one” so far. Daniel Craig is a wonderful actor and the role now fits him as a tailored Tom Ford tuxedo. Léa Seydoux also has great acting talents as she proved in movies such as The Lobster, Blue is The Warmest Color and La Belle Personne.

The James Bond and Madeleine Swann relationship is not wasted at all. But, surely, should have been better exploited and contextualized.

5 Responses

  1. Nicolás Suszczyk has raised some very good points. Most of all that the relationship could be explored more deeply. But then the paradox is created. Tracy was his only wife and deepest love. He did marry her with no strings attached. Yet there was nary a mention or reflection about the women he loved and left behind. So is SPECTRE happening before OHMSS as it appears or is it after? Still I would like to see where their relationship would have gone to since she does have some sort of understanding of an assassin’s life.

  2. The plot and script of Spectre, were in my opinion, very poor. None of the characters had a motivation to do anything that they did in the film – other than Blofeld’s random childhood jealousy. Bond & Swann’s relationship ended up being the worst part of it. Barely any time in the film was spent on the two of them and why they were any different than Bond and any other girl in the previous films. One minute she loves him, the next minute she’s leaving him in London, the next minute she and Bond are walking off together in the night.

    Definitely could’ve done with the whole London sequence being cut entirely and more time dealt with the characters. Odd to have a movie this long and feel like you barely got to know multiple of the new additions to the franchise.

  3. I enjoyed “SPECTRE” very much. Frankly, I consider it a major improvement over the numerous plot holes and misogyny of “SKYFALL”. But if “SPECTRE” had one major fault, it was the Madeline Swann character. As a solo character, I found her interesting. But Daniel Craig and Léa Seydoux had no real screen chemistry. And the Bond/Swann romance wasn’t developed very well.

  4. e did marry her with no strings attached. Yet there was nary a mention or reflection about the women he loved and left behind. So is SPECTRE happening before OHMSS as it appears or is it after?

    Has EON Productions announced any plans to remake “On Her Majesty’s Secret Service”? If not, why is this question being asked? Vesper Lynd had no role in the timeline of the 1962-2002 films. You haven’t considered the possibility that Tracy Di Vicenzo won’t be in this rebooted timeline.

  5. @drush76: While Eon never announced plans to remake OHMSS, the script, as late as October 2014, included a henchwoman named Irma Bunt. As late as December 2014, the last line in the script had Bond telling Madeleine, “We have all the time in the world.” All of this is known because of the Sony hacks.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: